Re: [coreboot] 8 GB DIMMs on Nehalem (Arrandale)

[Zoran Stojsavljevic]

Hello Stefan,

In addition what Charlotte wrote to you, I would advise you the following
(as general approach for mem problems):
[1] Please, for testing the memory, use secondary Coreboot payload called
MEMTEST:
[user@localhost coreboot]$ cat .config | grep MEMTEST
CONFIG_MEMTEST_SECONDARY_PAYLOAD=y
CONFIG_MEMTEST_STABLE=y
# CONFIG_MEMTEST_MASTER is not set

Instead going to SeaBIOS or GRUB2 as payloads. This memtest86+ could (my
best guess) show to you what is wrong with your memory configuration.

[2] You can also (since you are able to in some cases go to Linux) stop in
GRUB2, after installing from Linux memtest86+ package into the GRUB2 boot
options (this can also help too, my best guess).

(extra advise: if you use legacy/CSM ON, which is in Coreboot in 99.999%
cases used, it would be much easier for you to deal with memtest86+)

Best Regards,
Zoran

On Sat, Jan 21, 2017 at 11:55 AM, Stefan Tauner <
[e-mail]> wrote:
> Hi Vladimir,
>
> since you have REed the raminit for Nehalem I'd like you to ask if you
> have any knowledge, information or pointers about using 8 GB DIMMs with
> it or even using more than 8 GB in total. In my case it is about an
> Arrandale i5-520M (in a Thinkpad 410s).
>
> I know that an i7-820QM (Clarksfield) is perfectly capable of working
> with 8 GB DIMMs and probably up to 32 GB or even more (the Thinkpad
> W510 has 4 DIMM slots and I have tested it with 20 GB) and that is from
> around the same time as the Arrendale chips - which does not mean
> anything but I still refuse to accept that Nehalem is that limited. The
> official specs are not trustworthy IMHO and cpuid(1) and /proc/cpuinfo
> show the same physical address width of 36 bits (which would indicate a
> maximum of 64 GB).
>
> The current raminit for Nehalem in coreboot is not able to train the two
> 8 GB DIMMs I have tested so far. I have added a debug output to
> choose_reg178 in the first loop before the margins are compared to
> STANDARD_MIN_MARGIN that shows that all margins are 0. If there is
> anything I could try or information I can provide, please let me know.
>
> The (ancient) vendor firmware I've been using on the T410s does
> sometimes manage to boot Linux with an 8 GB DIMM (dmesg is attached
> including the e820 map), but it is quite broken and memtest86 locks up
> or reboots within seconds so that's probably not a good target for RE
> efforts. :)