I am mainly looking for opinions from both average sysadmins and power-users Here are two sample questions and my replies.
What stops you or has stopped you from using coreboot on your primary machines? (Gaming - It needs to play the latest games if I am to spend decent money on it as I don't have a good job right now - my D16 was my first purchase/flash once I found out I could do that and now I have a few other CB boards for other uses after I found out how really accessible coreboot is.)
How can the end-user documentation be improved?
What advantages are you looking for in a system that has open source (including init) firmware? (Me - freedom, repair-ability and semi-obscure features like IOMMU that actually work and can be easily fixed if they don't)
Some things I have done so far: Recommended cpus list for several popular boards, as buying a low end CPU then having unsatisfactory performance turns people away. Board notes to provide warnings and advisories for coreboot/board "gotchas" that discourage people, such as not knowing they need to run fancontrol to have a quiet system
Things I want to do: payload menuconfig for common payload configurations such as disabling option roms, loading grub.cfg's from disks, etc. List of boards with verified special functionality (iommu, egpu, etc)
Taiidan@gmx.com wrote:
Things I want to do: payload menuconfig for common payload configurations such as disabling option roms, loading grub.cfg's from disks, etc. List of boards with verified special functionality (iommu, egpu, etc)
That sounds great!
//Peter
Am 07.08.2017 um 23:50 schrieb Taiidan@gmx.com:
How can the end-user documentation be improved?
Hey. Great that you're interested in this special task.
For me as a non-contributing user much trouble occurs when trying to build anything beside SeaBIOS (Grub and FILO especially). Maybe a little tutorial about building these payloads would be cool. Especially the FILO docu is a bit thin. How do you configure it? What would be the main advantages over GRUB? etc.
What advantages are you looking for in a system that has open source (including init) firmware? (Me - freedom, repair-ability and semi-obscure features like IOMMU that actually work and can be easily fixed if they don't)
Personally I'm a great fan of technological efficiency in all my devices. I hate unnecessary crap laying around. When learning about x86 I always hated the fact that there's so much useless old stuff, that there's a BIOS and therefore some kind of second OS on a system while you actually only need one. That's why I like coreboot: Start the main board, give control to the OS and then be a nice firmware and go back to your flash-rom ;) I'm not as concerned about security and freedom as most of the other people probably. Unnecessary madness like the Intel Management Engine creeps me out a little bit, though.
P.