I've added a routine to grab the boot log for the board-status database from a serial device. I didn't realize at the time that it had already been voted down on the mailing list - I was told that if I wanted this to go in, I should appeal to the mailing list.
Please see the patch here: http://review.coreboot.org/#/c/6094/
Since there are currently some platforms that do not yet support the cbmem console, I would like to be able to grab the console from a serial device on the host side. I'm happy to mark it as coming from the serial device, and note in the script that by preference the cbmem console log should be used. I am fully prepared to add text to the script belittling anyone who has to fall back to such plebian measures or any other punishments that are deemed to be required.
Other possible alternatives I see to having the script read the console from a serial device: 1) Add a command line option to the board_status.sh script that allows the user to point to a file already containing the console log. 2) Add a command line option to allow the console log to just be skipped and upload the rest of the data without it. 3) Simply wait until the boards support cbmem console log and not push anything about those platforms until that point. 4) Collect the data manually and push it into the repo without the board_status.sh script being used.
My thought is that having the script grab the data from the serial port is better than any of these options, but I'm sure there are other possibilities that I've missed.
(Apologies if my tone offends anyone - I'm told that when I try to be funny, it comes across as condecension. I guess that's why I'm a programmer and not a comedian.) <-- my new tagline.
Martin
I think it's fine. The more info we have on a given board the better, and the boot log seems to be of value to people, so why not?
ron
On Thu, Jul 3, 2014 at 7:30 PM, Martin Roth martin.roth@se-eng.com wrote:
I've added a routine to grab the boot log for the board-status database from a serial device. I didn't realize at the time that it had already been voted down on the mailing list - I was told that if I wanted this to go in, I should appeal to the mailing list.
Please see the patch here: http://review.coreboot.org/#/c/6094/
Since there are currently some platforms that do not yet support the cbmem console, I would like to be able to grab the console from a serial device on the host side. I'm happy to mark it as coming from the serial device, and note in the script that by preference the cbmem console log should be used. I am fully prepared to add text to the script belittling anyone who has to fall back to such plebian measures or any other punishments that are deemed to be required.
Other possible alternatives I see to having the script read the console from a serial device:
- Add a command line option to the board_status.sh script that allows the
user to point to a file already containing the console log. 2) Add a command line option to allow the console log to just be skipped and upload the rest of the data without it. 3) Simply wait until the boards support cbmem console log and not push anything about those platforms until that point. 4) Collect the data manually and push it into the repo without the board_status.sh script being used.
My thought is that having the script grab the data from the serial port is better than any of these options, but I'm sure there are other possibilities that I've missed.
(Apologies if my tone offends anyone - I'm told that when I try to be funny, it comes across as condecension. I guess that's why I'm a programmer and not a comedian.) <-- my new tagline.
Martin
-- coreboot mailing list: coreboot@coreboot.org http://www.coreboot.org/mailman/listinfo/coreboot
-
Martin Roth -
ron minnich