On 29/09/2018, ron minnich rminnich@gmail.com wrote:
It's not a screw in Chromebooks any more, see vadim's excellent OSFC.io talk on how it works now.
Vadim Bendebury? This talk below?
https://osfc.io/talks/google-secure-microcontroller-and-ccd-closed-case-debu...
If so, is there a video or audio recording available? Thanks.
I think the momentary switch would not be acceptable to anyone for cost
Small momentary switches cost pennies and laptops usually have about a hundred of them fitted, of various kinds. (Power on/off/suspend; volume up/down; keyboard keys; maybe others.) So, fitting laptops with momentary switches is definitely acceptable to manufacturers.
and reliability reasons.
Such switches are often rated for ~100,000 cycles. It seems unlikely that any laptop or its owner would live long enough to flash the ROM chip even close to 100,000 times. So, I don't anticipate a reliability problem.
The way chromebooks do the protection now is really well done.
I look forward to reading Vadim's slides, and perhaps also to watching or listening to his talk. Thanks for the pointer.