Re: [SeaBIOS] new tag request for seabios

[Kevin O'Connor]

On Fri, Nov 21, 2014 at 07:04:47PM +0000, Pandey, Sunil K wrote:
> Hi Kevin,
>
> Thanks for response. Following are specific change I'm talking
> about. Compilers are not expected to create .rodata.str1.1,
> .rodata.__func__ and .rodata.__PRETTY_FUNCTION__.  If compiler
> decide to use some other .rodata__ suffix name in place of __func__,
> __PRETTY_FUNCTION__ or str1.1, it breaks the compilation.
>
> As you can see someone already taken out that check from SeaBios
> mainline, but 1.7.5.1 still has.  As a result of this assumption,
> whenever I try to build SeaBios with Intel Compiler it Fail because
> Intel compiler uses some other character in place of
> __PRETTY_FUNCTION__ and __func__. It will be great if you can
> incorporate this fix in released version.

I made that change as part of commit e5749978.  The change was part of
a feature enhancement (compiling with -fno-merge-constants).

Is this the only thing preventing compilation on the Intel compiler?

Typically a feature enhancement such as e5749978 would go into the
next release, and we're likely a month or so out from the next
release.

As Peter mentioned in another email, it should be possible to checkout
a git version using the hash instead of a tag name in the interim (eg,
"git checkout 9f505f71").

-Kevin

new tag request for seabios

[Pandey, Sunil K]

> Is this the only thing preventing compilation on the Intel compiler?
> Yes, this is the only problem for Intel compiler.

I can directly use from git checkout but issue is, SeaBios is indirectly included in many other open source applications which is based on SeaBios release tag. Anytime, when I try to compile other open source applications (i.e. Xen), indirectly it try to compile SeaBios and Intel Compiler fail because of this issue.

-----Original Message-----
From: Kevin O'Connor [mailto:[e-mail]] 
Sent: Friday, November 21, 2014 11:30 AM
To: Pandey, Sunil K
Cc: '[e-mail]'
Subject: Re: [SeaBIOS] new tag request for seabios

On Fri, Nov 21, 2014 at 07:04:47PM +0000, Pandey, Sunil K wrote:
> Hi Kevin,
>
> Thanks for response. Following are specific change I'm talking about. 
> Compilers are not expected to create .rodata.str1.1, .rodata.__func__ 
> and .rodata.__PRETTY_FUNCTION__.  If compiler decide to use some other 
> .rodata__ suffix name in place of __func__, __PRETTY_FUNCTION__ or 
> str1.1, it breaks the compilation.
>
> As you can see someone already taken out that check from SeaBios 
> mainline, but 1.7.5.1 still has.  As a result of this assumption, 
> whenever I try to build SeaBios with Intel Compiler it Fail because 
> Intel compiler uses some other character in place of 
> __PRETTY_FUNCTION__ and __func__. It will be great if you can 
> incorporate this fix in released version.

I made that change as part of commit e5749978.  The change was part of a feature enhancement (compiling with -fno-merge-constants).

Is this the only thing preventing compilation on the Intel compiler?

Typically a feature enhancement such as e5749978 would go into the next release, and we're likely a month or so out from the next release.

As Peter mentioned in another email, it should be possible to checkout a git version using the hash instead of a tag name in the interim (eg, "git checkout 9f505f71").

-Kevin