Michael Niewöhner has posted comments on this change. ( https://review.coreboot.org/c/coreboot/+/36328 )
Change subject: [RFC] Documentation/fsp: Discuss FSP-S issues ......................................................................
Patch Set 4:
Patch Set 4:
Patch Set 4: Code-Review+1
(1 comment)
Thanks for making the change. Also, sorry for any grief that I caused - We're on the same side, after all.
Ok, I've dropped it. Not that I would agree with you by a single percent. Just because it gives me a much too high blood pressure to discuss it with hotheads. There was no accusation whatsoever, not even a statement (beside the heading which was already true if a single person in the world has doubts). That the mere finding that somebody could be uncertain makes you uncomfortable makes me wonder what world you live in. If things are that bad in the US, sorry, you have my condolence.
I doubt it's just a US issue. Consider this: Have your complaints about FSP on the mailing list or Gerrit ever led to a positive outcome? Is there a German word for attempting the same thing many times over and expecting a different result?
Let me translate this... you say one should stop discussing a topic just because the opponent does not want to discuss it? This is what I'd call "giving up".
I *really* don't see where dropping that part should help in any way and I don't see why one wouldn't discuss the other topics in the document because there is *some* "legal speculation".
btw. I found at least five more paragraphs that would need removal too under your statements ;)