[coreboot] Time for a new project

pk peka at min-epost.net
Sun Apr 13 23:31:34 CEST 2008

Jordan Crouse wrote:

> How best can we make a decision then?  A vote, perhaps?  I had wondered if
> we could do a discussion and "vote" on the wiki in grand Wikipedian style,
> but not everybody has an account, and I don't want to exclude anybody.  I
> don't know if Stefan can turn on IP editing for individual pages or not.
> if that doesn't work, I guess we'll try to do it via email.
> Either way, I think we should reset the decks and allow representatives from
> both sides make their arguments.  I nominate Segher for the "ELF is best"
> and Ron for the "ELF is not best" arguments.   Remember, this is not over
> the merits of SELF, but rather, if we should abandon ELF at all.
> Thoughts?


Sorry to "butt in" on the discussion here...

Maybe I'm misunderstanding something here but why not put up a 
comparison chart (strengths/weaknesses) of ELF/SELF on the wiki (or 
somewhere)? I don't know if it can be easily done, since I'm not fully 
grasping the details, but if it is then it should give you an overview 
of their individual technical merits to vote on instead of voting based 
on "belief" (that's how I perceive the situation).

I'll crawl back under my rock now...

Best regards

Peter K

More information about the coreboot mailing list